Greetings, those of good will.

I've created this blog to register my experience through this PhD in London, UK. Welcome to a space for discussion of new ideas within digital interfaces, eye tracking, assistive technology, natural user interfaces, physical and tangible computing, gestural interfaces, upcoming devices, web 2/3.0, augmented reality and beyond.
Showing posts with label Fluid Interfaces. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Fluid Interfaces. Show all posts

Tuesday, 3 September 2013

Flat And Thin Are In

Flat And Thin Are In

In the last several years, we’ve seen a rapid shift in software and app interface design, from 3-D and skeuomorphic to flat and minimal. Although this trend has become nearly ubiquitous, let’s take a moment to consider how we got here and what influence it’s having on interface design as a whole. Additionally, I’ll share some tips and considerations on designing flat interfaces.
mobile_os
Interfaces on a Windows Phone 8 and Apple’s iOS 7.

What Happened?

So, how did the collective consciousness swing from a love of all things textured, beveled and drop-shadowed to a desire for flat colors and simple typography? Many factors have fuelled this transition, but here are a few that stand out.

Information Overload

As a constantly connected culture, we deal with a nonstop flow of information, some of it important and relevant, most of it not. We are constantly evaluating, filtering and, of course, creating content, and it all gets pretty exhausting. In addition, much of our content consumption has moved to devices with small screens, thus exacerbating that feeling of overload. Becoming overwhelmed is all too easy, and a reduction of clutter in a user interface (UI) can create a little visual zen.
Geckoboard
Free of clutter: Geckoboard‘s visualisations are designed to make key data easy to interpret at a glance.

Simplicity Is Golden

In a similar trend, a lot of disruptive Web apps and services are offering highly focused tools with extremely limited feature sets. Whereas traditional software developers tend to load their products with a glut of features to justify the high price tags, this shift towards focused micro-apps favors simplicity over feature set. Simpler apps mean simpler interfaces.
blue
Beautiful and minimal: The Blue weather app by Oak.

Content Is King, Again

As so often happens when new devices and technologies enter the market, we become fascinated by what they can do and how we can advance interactivity. This interface frenzy is usually followed by a return to a focus on content. Media consumption, whether of text, audio or video, is probably the activity we engage in most on our devices, and for that use case, we just want the interface to get out of the way.

Technological Literacy

As smartphone and tablet adoption has rapidly penetrated all user demographics, concern about the obviousness of controls has reduced. Whereas we once feared that users might miss a button if it didn’t pop off the screen, we are now willing to explore subtler interactions. Windows 8 and Chrome for Android even support touch commands that start off screen, without any visual indicator.
fitbit_dashboard
Fitbit’s dashboard is a bright, bold, and easy approachable visual identity.

Technology’s Influence

Most software will be limited by the platform on which it runs. Screen dimensions and pixel density are the confining factors of hardware. A minimal interface demands a very limited design palette, which means that every element needs to sing. Typographic scale and font weight will largely determine both the aesthetics and usability of a flat design.
If your target devices can’t handle that level of nuance, you’re out of luck. As screen size and pixel density continue to increase on mobile devices, thinner and smaller type can be presented with better clarity. Of course, support for @font-face has also boosted the appeal of minimal typographic-focused designs.
wallmob
Live sales monitoring with Wallmob: keeping track of the figures from any device that has a browser.

Responsive Design

With the proliferation of connected devices of various dimensions, UIs have had to become more fluid, and the responsive design movement has responded. While responsive design does not call for a particular aesthetic, one could certainly argue that flat UIs lend themselves to it more easily than many other styles. The other advantage of minimal design is the reduction in page weight and loading time.
onsiteio
To the point and weightless: OnSite. (Larger view)

Best Practices

OK, enough with the theory. Let’s get down to some practical considerations. Creating an effective minimal design is surprisingly challenging. As you strip away common UI tricks (drop shadows, bevels, textures and the like), you quickly realize how important the few remaining elements become. While the following tips are mostly universally applicable, they are especially relevant to flat UIs.

Before You Begin

As with any project, the first step is to ensure that your chosen style makes sense. Before diving into a flat design, make sure it aligns with your target users’ sensibilities and your target platform, devices and application type. Following a trend is pointless if it’s the wrong solution for your project.

Process

The process you follow is pretty important, no matter what style you are adopting. Here are some ideas to keep in mind when aiming for simplicity.
  • When designing a minimal interface, I often seek inspiration from the pre-PC era, when designers and artists did more with less. This is a perfect opportunity to revisit some of the design greats, such as Josef Müller-Brockmann and Wim Crouwel. I also look to minimal painters such as Ellsworth Kelly, architects such as Mies van der Rohe and industrial designers such as Dieter Rams.
  • Walking away from the work is also helpful. Flat and minimal design is all about nuance. So, taking a break and coming back later with fresh eyes is often more effective than hammering away.
  • Comparing versions side by side is also helpful. After moving a line of type up and down by 5 pixels for 20 minutes, I’ll save two versions and compare them; the better option is quickly revealed.
  • Because the relative scale of objects plays such a critical role, check your design concepts on a variety of target devices early on to confirm that they work.
  • As you work, keep asking yourself, “Do I really need that?” Getting attached to an item that you find clever is so easy, but we must always look for elements to cut or simplify. Ditching something that you’ve put so much work into is always hard, but editing is critical.
globalcloset
Global Closet: an interactive game designed for National Geographic Education by The Workshop.

Grid

The grid plays a crucial role in so much of interface design, and no exception here. As you attempt to establish order and make usability intuitive across a project with a restricted set of visual elements, the grid is there to help.
  • The grid establishes more than visual order. Use it to define content and functional groups. You don’t always need a line or box to group a set of objects. Simple alignment and spacing can help the user understand an interface’s structure.
  • Try breaking the grid with elements of particular importance to really draw the user’s attention. Without fake 3-D trickery, basic layout principles such as scale and placement become the best elements by which to establish visual hierarchy.
  • Experiment with a denser grid than you are accustomed to working with. When you dramatically reduce the visual palette, you may find that the design supports a more complex structure without feeling messy. See what additional information you can convey through placement alone.
live_school
Live School iPad app by Rossul Design.

Color

Obviously, color is always a key component of visual design. With minimal interfaces, it is even more critical.
  • Consider a broader palette. If you’re like me, then you feel that a narrower palette usually leads to a more functional interface. Ending up with an overwhelming rainbow is all too easy. Here’s your chance to really stretch; and with so few elements to work with, you can feel good about expanding the palette.
  • When setting the palette, test your selected hues across a wide value spectrum to make sure they behave in lighter and darker versions.
  • You’ll probably want to experiment with tone on tone and stark type. Experiment with your palette early on to ensure that you have enough range for both subtle and high-contrast elements.
trippleagent
TriplAgent‘s visual design makes use of a stunning color palette.

Typography

When it comes to flat content-driven websites, typography is the hero.
  • While serifs are certainly an option, san serifs almost always feel cleaner.
  • Look for a font family with a wide variety of weights and styles. You certainly don’t need to use them all, but a broad selection will help you define the hierarchy more sharply, and you might also find that certain weights render better in certain environments.
  • Don’t be afraid to pair fonts with extreme differences in size and weight to create visual order. Try pairing an oversized ultra-thin font for headlines with a small medium-weight font for the body.
  • Watch out for legibility in fonts. It sounds silly, I know, but you will be asking a lot from your chosen fonts, so make sure they have great legibility at any scale.
siteleaf
Clean and legible typography on Siteleaf.

Interaction

In a flat UI, indicating that an element is interactive can be tricky. Here are a few methods I rely on.
  • Contrast is key. If the majority of the layout is white, then you could give interactive elements some color. If the design is primarily text-driven, then you could use simple iconography. If the headlines are large and all lowercase, you could make links small and all uppercase. You get the idea.
  • Conventional placement helps as well. If you use a slim chevron for a back arrow, place it in the upper-left corner, where users would expect to find the back button.
  • As you layer more features on the page, making every interactive element look like a button wouldn’t make sense. The interface should be as intuitive as possible. But in cases where interaction is particularly complex or unexpected, make it easy to recover from mistakes.
  • Drop-downs, modal windows, fly-outs and other layered elements can be troublesome to implement in a flat design. Leverage sharp contrast, borders or tinting to visually separate the levels of interaction.
taasky
Design elements presented in a simple layout and with optimal contrasts: Taasky.

Wrapping Up

I don’t believe in hard and fast rules in design. Seeing designers so heavily invested in creating extremely clean and simple user interfaces is pretty awesome. Does exploring flat design mean using absolutely no gradients or shadows? Of course not. In fact, some of the most intriguing work I’ve seen recently balances flatness and dimension by presenting content intelligently while keeping the interaction intuitive.
In this highly connected, information-rich and feature-packed digital world we live in, minimal design’s widespread resurgence is refreshing to witness. It is by no means the right solution for everything (no style is), but when applied thoughtfully and appropriately, it makes for a highly usable and enjoyable digital experience.
(al) (ea)
Smashing Library Smashing Workshops We've got quite a line-up of full-day workshops for you in Germany. Join Brad Frost, Luke Wroblewski, Lea Verou, Rachel Andrew, Jonathan Snook, Eva Lotta-Lamm and get better and smarter. Grab your bag and join us!

Full-Day Smashing Workshops →
Adrian is an Interactive Creative Director and Principal at Pushstart Creative, a multidisciplinary agency focused on the convergence of physical product, interactive technology and brand experience. While much of his current work is focused on research, strategy development, and UX he will always have a passion for pushing pixels. Stop by designtaylor.com or find Adrian on Twitter.
  1. 1
    This is really Great .. Enjoyed the article very Much .. FLAT is the New ‘Sexy’
  2. 2
    One important thing to note is that Flat UI interfaces might look simplistic on screenshots. Most of them have rich animations that catch the users eye. Its not like those flash-websites from the old days, but engaging nonetheless.
  3. 3
    The Author and the Design Community seem to have no historic Memory or Google Fu whatsoever.
    Before the Pseudo-3D Style was made so simple even Pixel Monkeys could do it with Shadows and Light Effects – everything was “flat”.
    Wrong Argument #1: Flat Design reduced Information Overload.
    Any UX-Designer or IA will tell you that the Interfaces hold the same Amount of Information – just the visual Representation is less ornamental.
    ———-
    Wrong Argument #2: Flat Design is “simple” or brings Simplicity.
    Not it isn’t. It is made to look simple. It a Question of Perception, not Reduction or Simplification of the Interface and it’s Elements.
    The Author confuses Simplicity with Reduction. For example GMails new Compose Windows looks simpler, because it has reduced the Number of Elements – but it also means that the User has to make more conceptual Leaps to get his Tasks done. To open the Formatting Option you now require an additional Click just to open that Toolbar – which means the User has to remember the Interface and even understand the conceptional Leap that a certain Icon represents the Formatting Option.
    Once again it’s about Perception: the Interface is not simpler and nor is it a Simplification of the actual Functionality and Workflow – but Eye Candy and hiding perfectly useful Function for the Sake or being cool and trendy.
    So Simplification often causes unnecessary conceptional and cognitive Leaps by the User – hardly an Achievement in Terms of good Usability and actual Simplicity.
    ———-
    Wrong Argument #3: Obviousness of Controls
    No, not everyone immediately gets every Interface, even when they have worked for Decades with Gadgets and Computers.
    Why shouldn’t Controls be obvious, clearly identified and labelled?
    Because Designers are bored of doing their Homework? Or because Buttons spoil their pretty Photoshop Designs?
    Unless you customizable Interfaces or a Pro and Beginner Version any Interface should be as comprehendable and clear as possible.
    Even so called digital Natives are often not as sophisticated as they think and any Interface requires a learning Curve as well as conceptional Leaps.
    The Designer should provide a solid Interface and possible a Choice for the User to customize his/her Experience – Empowering the User doesn’t mean hiding Stuff, just because we ASSSUME the User has it all figured out.
    Especially Google has that terrible Habit of making their Offerings “Auto-Awesome”, which doesn’t empower the User, but make him/her a Bystander in the Workflow. This takes away the Chance of actually learning a Tool and some Skills as well as Choices with the Workflow / Creative Process.
    This dumbs down the Users – it doesn’t empower them. Power comes from Knowledge and Knowledge comes from Learning. Take away the Chance of Learning and you get a Pavlovian Button-Presser.
    ———
    Contrast is King? The Author illustrates his Points by using many Screenshots that have miserable Typography and Colour Choices that have hardly any Contrast at all.
    This is currently very prevalent in Flat Design: dark Grey Typo on medium Grey Background – no Contrast at all (this also applies to the Example of White Type of Yellow Background). Often they also use very delicate / thin Fonts that offer also no Contrast, especially on mobile Devices in Sunlight.
    • 4
      I agree with your point about Google’s gmail. Having been a gmail user for nearly a decade now, I can testify that their interface has introduced a new learning curve every time they changed it.
      It’s actually really confusing and things are misplaced. Example, signing out and settings are in two different areas that are hidden away.
    • 5
      You seem to know a lot about design.
      Can you also give some design advice in addition to your (constructive?) criticism? Like what do you consider good typography or contrast color schemes? And how would you make interactions obvious?
  4. 6
    I think perhaps the shift could also have something to do with the fact that when smartphones first emerged, users would have had less understanding of how the interface worked in general, as they were so different to older style feature phones; so it was made as realistic as possible to make them feel like they instantly knew how to use it.
    Nowadays, people innately know how to use a smartphone/tablet so the interface is allowed to become less obvious, more stripped back, and that kind of paves the way for a ‘simpler’ design.
  5. 7
    Great article. Flat design comes more naturally to me. I am working on a site now that that uses different shades of blue and to contrast that a bright green. I love flat, clean, responsive design
  6. 8
    @Dieter thanks for your thoughtful and thorough reply. “Flat” design always get’s the opinions flowing! I don’t necessarily disagree with the points you’ve raised but I did want to clarify a few items.
    Argument #1: Flat Design reduced Information Overload.
    I agree that there is the same about of media (text, image, video, etc.) in a flat design as in a more dimensional design however I would argue that every item in a design requires effort by the user to decode. Less elements often means less work. Now this is not to say that you can’t make a dimensional design easy to parse, just an example of a possible benefit.
    Argument #2: Flat Design is “simple” or brings Simplicity.
    I agree with you here and don’t believe that I ever made that argument that flat inherently creates simplicity. In fact, I would suggest that a reduced use of dimensionally in your design often makes it more difficult to create an obvious / intuitive interface. Good usability and aesthetic style are separate concerns. I do feel that when designs attempt to work with a reduced visual pallet it can help to focus their efforts on usability rather than decoration, but not always. I think we both agree that simplicity is hard to do right.
    Argument #3: Obviousness of Controls
    I think we are actually aligned on this point. Flat does not make things more obvious, it often makes them less so. When designing flat you must work even harder to make things intuitive. A big shinny button with a drop shadow is almost always going to be more obvious then a thin white arrow on a flat background. Before working flat designs must consider whether it is the right style for their audience and then word diligently to ensure usability.
    Thanks again for your thoughts!

Leave a Comment

Thursday, 25 November 2010

MIT Media Lab: DepthJS

Video from Fluid Interfaces in Vimeo - group that belongs to the MIT Media Lab. The goal of the Fluid Interfaces research group is to radically rethink the human-machine interactive experience. By designing interfaces that are more immersive, more intelligent, and more interactive we are changing the human-machine relationship and creating systems that are more responsive to people's needs and actions, and that become true "accessories" for expanding our minds.

The project below uses Kinect + Computer Vision + Javascript. DepthJS is a web browser extension that allows any any web page to interact with the Microsoft Kinect via Javascript:


DepthJS from Fluid Interfaces on Vimeo.